Staff Picks

Miley Cyrus and Ann Wilson Took Different Roads to the Top of ‘Dream On’

Miley Cyrus and Ann Wilson both sang Aerosmith’s “Dream On,” and the most revealing comparison comes well before either performance reaches its loudest point. One comes from a television arrangement with four coaches. The other follows a single singer over a piano-led opening in a concert room.

On The Voice in 2016, Cyrus shared the song with Alicia Keys, Adam Levine and Blake Shelton. The first thing to listen for is the change in texture as the lines pass between them. Cyrus brings a rougher edge when she comes forward, so a familiar phrase suddenly draws attention to the singer delivering it.

At Hampton Beach in 2021, Wilson was 71 and kept the opening close. The piano and her voice carry the early lines. With one singer holding the story, the change in scale comes partly from what the band adds around her and partly from the way she opens up the vocal.

The arrangement determines a great deal of what an audience notices. A singer entering a shared performance has the space of a short passage to make an impression. With a solo vocal, a phrase can take on more force because you have heard the same voice deliver several quieter ones first.

Both recordings reward a replay. On the first pass, listen for the vocal entrances. On the second, follow what is happening underneath them. The accompaniment, the timing of the vocal handoffs and the space around each phrase contribute as much to the buildup as the number of singers onstage.

The order below gives Cyrus’s ensemble performance first, then Wilson’s Hampton Beach cover, followed by Aerosmith’s studio recording. Hearing the three openings together makes it easier to notice which part of the original each arrangement brings forward.

Miley Cyrus and The Voice coaches perform ‘Dream On’

The Voice clip draws momentum from changes in who is singing. The Hampton Beach clip gives Wilson time to show how much the same voice can change over the course of a song. Each approach gives the listener a reason to stay with the early lines.

Aerosmith’s recording brings the focus back to the shape of the song itself. Steven Tyler’s original path from the restrained opening to the climax is strong enough to hold up when the arrangement and the performer change.

Two more recordings

Ann Wilson sings ‘Dream On’ at Hampton Beach
Aerosmith’s original ‘Dream On’

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *