Staff Picks

The Las Vegas ‘Black Dog’ Cover That Made a Fan Call Miley Cyrus a Rocker

One viewer watching Miley Cyrus sing Led Zeppelin’s ‘Black Dog’ in Las Vegas joked that her pop hits paid the bills and that she was a rocker at heart. The performance arrived a few songs into her 2019 iHeartRadio Music Festival set. After ‘Mother’s Daughter,’ the guitar in ‘Black Dog’ immediately announces a different kind of song.

The cover works as a setlist decision as well as a standalone performance. ‘Mother’s Daughter’ delivers its momentum with a steady pulse. ‘Black Dog’ moves in bursts. A vocal line opens a gap, the guitar fills it, and then the band has to leave enough space for the next line.

Cyrus keeps her voice close to the microphone through those exchanges. The roughness in the sound can be intimate even while she’s projecting in an arena. When the players return with the riff, their entrance gives her something strong to push against on the next phrase.

The close shots help explain why that viewer heard such a strong rock identity in this performance. You can see Cyrus prepare for the phrases and give them more force when the band answers. Her phrasing and the guitar keep taking turns at the front of the sound.

Later in the set she also covered Pink Floyd’s ‘Comfortably Numb.’ The two choices give a sense of how wide the night’s rock material was. The Zeppelin song brings a tightly wound call and response. The Pink Floyd cover gives her a different kind of space to work with.

Start with the complete ‘Black Dog’ clip, then use the longer concert recording to hear what came before and after. The song works on its own, and its place in the Las Vegas set gives the guitar’s first entrance an extra jolt.

Miley Cyrus performs ‘Black Dog’ at the 2019 iHeartRadio Music Festival

Led Zeppelin’s concert version offers the clearest reference for the vocal and guitar exchanges Cyrus and her band have to negotiate. Every return of the riff has to arrive cleanly for the shape of the cover to hold.

The longer iHeartRadio set also includes ‘Comfortably Numb.’ Try starting there after ‘Black Dog’ and listen to how Cyrus’s voice sits in a cover with a different pace and much longer stretches of sustained accompaniment.

Two more recordings

Led Zeppelin plays ‘Black Dog’ live
‘Comfortably Numb’ from the same iHeartRadio set

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *