Staff Picks

The First Verse Cynthia Erivo Made Worth Replaying at Rock Hall

There’s a reason to replay the first verse of Cynthia Erivo’s “In the Air Tonight” at the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame. Listen to the ends of the lines. She gives the words time to land before she takes her next breath, and lets a note taper off when she has enough room to make it bigger.

Erivo sang the song in tribute to Phil Collins on November 14, 2026, in Los Angeles. Travis Barker was behind the kit, and anyone who recognized the song knew what he would eventually get to play. That familiarity gives the singer an unusual job in the opening. The audience is already listening for a sound that hasn’t arrived yet.

Collins’s original vocal establishes the tension without explaining it. The accompaniment stays spare enough that you can hear changes in his delivery from one line to the next. Erivo follows that part of the design while finding a different way to move through the words.

Start with how she enters. There’s very little force behind the first phrase. The voice comes forward by degrees, so a long vowel or a rougher edge later in the verse makes more of an impression. The first verse works because those choices are small enough that you have to come toward the singer to catch them.

Once Barker enters in earnest, the kit changes the size of the performance. Going back to the beginning after hearing that louder passage lets you hear what Erivo was already doing on her own. The change in dynamics takes more than a drummer coming in at the expected point.

The first recording starts at the beginning of the performance. Play the opening all the way through and see how the space between the early lines feels once you know where the song is going.

The other angle captures the words with a different room sound. What carries between the two recordings is Erivo’s timing. You can hear the shape of the lines even when the balance between the microphone and the room changes.

Then compare the first verse with Collins’s original. Both performances know that the drums can wait. Listen to what each singer chooses to do with that time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *