Staff Picks

What Changes When Andrea Bocelli Takes the Melody From Brian May in Tuscany

At Teatro del Silenzio, Brian May gives the first part of “Who Wants to Live Forever” a human scale. His voice is warm and close to the words. When Andrea Bocelli enters, the melody begins to travel differently. Bocelli’s tenor carries farther through the arrangement, and you hear the contrast most clearly because May has already drawn the listener in.

The setting was the 2024 anniversary celebration for Bocelli at the outdoor theatre in Lajatico, Tuscany. May had come to sing a song he wrote and first recorded with Queen. The footage offers a good way to see what a songwriter can bring to a familiar piece after other voices have become so closely associated with it. He knows exactly how much the opening needs.

One pleasure of the performance is that the two men keep the difference between their voices. May keeps the question close when he introduces it, while Bocelli can take the line out into a fuller sound. The transfer is worth following in the video. Listen to the space May leaves around the end of his first phrases and how much more length Bocelli can find as the arrangement opens.

That movement between voices is part of the 1986 Queen recording as well. May sings at the beginning and Freddie Mercury takes over as the song grows. In Tuscany, the sound that arrives after May differs from both men. Bocelli brings an operatic weight without changing the relationship between a quiet opening and the much larger feeling that follows.

May wrote the song for Highlander. In the band’s account of the film, he recalled responding to the idea of someone who can outlive the people he loves. It helps to hear the duet with that story in mind. A quiet voice can tell you more about a person facing that prospect than a grand sound can tell you on its own. Bocelli gives that private feeling a longer reach once it’s established.

The full Tuscany clip is the place to hear the change happen without interruption. Queen’s original version is worth playing next, and the band’s Highlander feature explains where those different scales of feeling came from. It’s a useful way to hear how a familiar chorus can feel different when a different voice takes it up.

Andrea Bocelli and Brian May perform in Tuscany

May comes back into the conversation with his guitar. The sound is recognisable from records made long before this evening, yet the point of hearing it here is the way it answers the tenor. The duet makes space for the songwriter, the singer and the guitarist who happens to be the same person.

Related performances

Queen’s 1986 “Who Wants to Live Forever” video
Brian May and Queen talk about Highlander

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *