Staff Picks

Metallica Kept the Sound of ‘Nothing Else Matters’ and Left Room for Miley Cyrus

Miley Cyrus takes the lead on ‘Nothing Else Matters’ with Metallica beside her, and part of the surprise is how familiar the song still sounds. The guitar figure establishes the shape of the original. Cyrus enters with a lower, grainier delivery than listeners may expect from her, and there is room for that voice inside the arrangement from the first verse.

The band played the song with her for The Howard Stern Show in 2021, during the Black Album’s thirtieth anniversary. It was the first live performance of Cyrus and Metallica together. Their rendition is separate from the all-star version released on The Metallica Blacklist, which put Cyrus in a different arrangement alongside musicians including Elton John and Yo-Yo Ma.

Hetfield had once been reluctant to bring the song to Metallica. A private idea from a musician away from home, it sounded unlike the kind of material people expected from the band. Once it found a home on the Black Album, the tenderness became part of how a much wider audience understood what Metallica could do.

Cyrus had already tried the song before appearing with the band. She has described singing it at Glastonbury during a period in which she had lost her home to a wildfire and her marriage was coming to an end. That history helps explain what the song meant to her. The Stern performance also makes sense on its own terms as a singer taking care over the way the melody lies in her voice.

Listen to what changes when Hetfield joins her around the chorus. Cyrus can keep the texture that gives the first verse its weight, while his voice brings a familiar point of reference back into the arrangement. The overlap makes it easier to hear the two interpretations together instead of measuring one against a memory of the other.

The filmed studio performance starts with the song’s quiet introduction. Give the first verse time before listening for the place where Hetfield’s voice becomes more prominent. The line still sounds like Metallica, and the voice carrying it has a character of its own.

Miley Cyrus and Metallica perform Nothing Else Matters on The Howard Stern Show

Metallica’s performance with the San Francisco Symphony is another way to hear how much movement the guitar part can support. Cyrus’s vocal version keeps the same melody at a more intimate scale.

Metallica and the San Francisco Symphony perform Nothing Else Matters

Her cover of ‘Heart of Glass’ puts that grain in her voice to different use. The comparison makes the careful control of the quieter delivery in ‘Nothing Else Matters’ easier to hear.

Miley Cyrus performs Heart of Glass at the iHeart Festival

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *