Why Cynthia Erivo Was Such a Good Choice to Sing Phil Collins at Rock Hall
A fan watching Cynthia Erivo sing “In the Air Tonight” had a question about the casting, and it came in the form of a compliment. “Whoever asked Cynthia Erivo to cover In the Air Tonight needs a raise. Simply brilliant!” The performance at the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame offers a few ways to hear what they meant.
Erivo and Travis Barker performed the song on November 14 at the Peacock Theater in Los Angeles, where Phil Collins was inducted as a solo artist. Barker had already introduced Collins to the room. When he took his place behind the drum kit, Erivo had the job of carrying the first part of a song whose ending many people could play from memory.
Her opening is unusually close and quiet. She lets the words settle before pushing the melody out into the room. That choice gives the performance a point of view from its first line. The voice sounds as though it is addressing one person before it has to fill a theater.
Collins’s 1981 recording makes the singer and the drummer part of the same dramatic build. At the ceremony two musicians divided that work. Erivo could shape the words and stretch a phrase while Barker held his entrance. The distance between the microphone and the kit made their timing visible, too.
The pairing also leaves room for two distinct kinds of recognition. Barker brings back the drum figure listeners know from Collins’s recording. Erivo makes familiar words sound like they’re being thought through in the moment. Listen to where the voice grows louder before the drums arrive, then notice how much of that phrasing she keeps once the kit is in.
The full performance is below. The opening verse and the first passage after the fill tell the story of the arrangement better than either sound bite does on its own.
A second recording puts more of the stage in view. It’s easier to follow Barker while Erivo sings, especially through the last few lines before he comes in. The broad view also shows how far apart the performers are as they build to the same entrance.
There is a reason some viewers focused on the choice of singer. A tribute has to remind the room what it loves about a record while giving it a reason to listen to this version. Erivo finds that reason in the opening verse, well before anyone gets to play air drums.
Collins’s original recording offers a useful comparison. Listen for how both versions hold back early, and for the different ways the two singers let the words land.





